Should Athletes Fast During Matches? Mohammed Shami’s Roza Debate Explained
Mohammed Shami’s Fasting Controversy: Faith, Cricket, and Public Opinion
Indian cricketer Mohammed Shami has found himself in the middle of a controversy, not for his performance but for not fasting (Roza) during Ramadan. During the Champions Trophy semi-final against Australia, Shami was seen drinking water on the field, which sparked criticism from some religious leaders. While some believe that fasting is mandatory, others, including Islamic scholars and public figures, have supported Shami, stating that Islam allows exceptions for travelers and those engaged in physically demanding jobs.
What Sparked the Controversy?
The controversy began when Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi, the President of the All India Muslim Jamaat, criticized Shami for drinking water during the match. He went as far as to call him a “criminal” for not observing Roza. According to him, every Muslim, regardless of their profession, should observe fasting during Ramadan. His statement led to a heated debate on whether professional athletes should be required to fast while playing important matches.
What Does Islam Say About Fasting?
Islam considers fasting (Roza) as one of the five pillars, but it also provides flexibility for those who cannot fast due to specific reasons. Quran (Surah Al-Baqarah 2:184-185) states: “Those who are ill or traveling may postpone their fast and make up for it later.” Cricket is a high-intensity sport, especially for a fast bowler like Shami. Playing under the scorching sun while fasting can severely impact performance and health. The Quran clearly allows travelers and those engaged in physically demanding activities to break their fast and compensate later. This means that Shami’s decision to not fast is in line with Islamic teachings, yet some critics refuse to acknowledge this religious flexibility.
Who is Supporting Shami and Who is Against Him?
✅ Supporters of Mohammed Shami
1️⃣ Congress Leader Shama Mohamed – She strongly defended Shami, stating that “Islam is a scientific religion, and it allows flexibility in special situations.” She added, “Good deeds matter more than rituals.”
2️⃣ Islamic Scholars and Experts – Many scholars clarified that Shami was within his religious rights to skip fasting during such a physically exhausting event.
3️⃣ Cricket Fans and Fellow Athletes – Several fans and ex-cricketers supported Shami, pointing out that athletes need proper hydration and nutrition to perform well.
❌ Critics of Mohammed Shami
1️⃣ Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi – He accused Shami of “setting a bad example for other Muslims.” He insisted that “if other Muslim athletes can fast, Shami should too.”
2️⃣ Radical Islamic Groups – Some social media users lashed out at Shami, arguing that fasting should not be compromised, no matter the circumstances.
Has This Happened Before? Other Athletes Who Faced Similar Issues
This is not the first time a Muslim athlete has been criticized for either fasting or not fasting during professional games.
🏀 Hakeem Olajuwon (NBA Legend) – He observed Ramadan fasting while playing at the highest level. He credited his faith for giving him strength on the court.
⚽ Paul Pogba (French Football Star) – He played competitive matches while fasting and said it made him mentally stronger.
🏏 Moeen Ali (England Cricket Team) – He fasted while playing and said it was a part of his faith and discipline.
However, many Muslim athletes choose to delay their fast due to intense physical exertion, which is completely allowed in Islam.
What Can We Learn from This?
🔥 Respect Personal Choices – Faith is a personal matter, and no one should be judged for how they practice their religion.
📖 Understand Islamic Teachings Properly – The Quran allows flexibility in fasting. Those who travel or do strenuous work can postpone their fast without guilt.
💪 Health and Performance Matter – Cricket is a physically demanding sport. Athletes need to stay hydrated and energetic to perform at their best.
Final Thoughts: Should Shami Be Criticized?
✅ No, Mohammed Shami should NOT be criticized. ✅ His decision to not fast is fully justified by Islamic teachings. ✅ Religion is about understanding, not blind criticism.
This controversy is a reminder that religion and profession can coexist, but individual choices must be respected. It’s time to move beyond criticism and embrace the true essence of faith – understanding and compassion.
🔥 What’s Your Take? Should Athletes Fast During Important Matches? Comment Below!
(For more trending sports updates, stay tuned! 🚀)